Hudler vs. St. Louis

Can't believe I'm asking this, and I know the right answer, but I need some support...

I have: Hudler on pace for 70 with 42 on the PP. I don't think the PPP will be that high, but 70 is definitely attainable.

I'd get: St. Louis on pace for 59, which should start rising... but will he really be that much better an option? Yes, he has broken 100, but he's also gone 70-94-61-102-83, meaning a 65 point season is possible, especially with the new ownership deciding to run the team...

Roto, 82 max; G, A, +/-, PIM, PPP, GWG
Risk: I end up losing 5 points
Reward: St. Louis wakes up and I gain 10-15 points

...and yet I can't quite do it. Convince me?

St. Louis plays on the top line with LeCavalier and a nice powerplay. He's a lock for 60 and should easily get 70. Hudler hopefully will get 60 while 70 seems unlikely.

I would definitely go with St. Louis - he's the proven stud who's the #2 player on his team vs. Hudler who despite his points on the man advantage sits much lower on Detroit's depth chart.

ya just doooooo it

stlouis trade value could skyrocket at some point in the season and u can go for hudler and rafalski for him with the same owner... u cant really lose.

i also have st.louis and upset he isnt doing better but he has 5 points in his last 5 games, and lecav is picking it up as well so i am just waiting for him to break out in a big way.

as for hudler he is good but buried in det. he is only averaging like 13 - 15 mins a game at most. st.louis is getting like 20 if not more.