Sidney Crosby vs. Connor McDavid (Part 1)

Rick Roos

2015-06-24

SidneyCrosby3

 

Roos examines the fantasy value of Crosby (circa 2005) versus McDavid (circa 2015)

 

 

 

After years of hype and months of focus on where exactly he'll land, in two days Connor McDavid finally gets drafted by an NHL team (barring something crazy, to Edmonton first overall). And although Cage Match normally compares players based on actual NHL data in order to predict future performance, I simply couldn't resist the opportunity to pay homage to McDavid, who's already been anointed this decade's "generational talent," ala Sidney Crosby in the 2000s, Eric Lindros in the 1990s, Mario Lemieux in the 1980s, and Wayne Gretzky in the 1970s.

190 (22nd)

18.0% (7th)

None

 

Looking at this data, it's remarkable how alike both teams were in terms of their offensive outputs. Beyond that, we need to remember that the NHL also was in the midst of a similarly non-offensive era 10 years ago:

 

 

Season

90+ point scorers

70+ point scorers

Points for 50th highest NHL scorer

Points for 100th highest NHL scorer

2014-15

None

19

60

47

2003-04

One

20

55

46

 

From the data in these tables, McDavid appears to be walking into a scoring environment (both for his team and the NHL as a whole) that's eerily similar to Crosby's rookie season, when Crosby tallied 102 points. But appearances can be deceiving…..

Remember that the 2004-05 NHL season was canceled due to a lockout, and post-lockout rules changes that took effect for 2005-06 were heavily weighted toward trying to generate more scoring. And that's exactly what happened, as in 2005-06 nine players ended up with more than the 94 points that had led the league in scoring in 2003-04, with seven going so far as to post 100+ points, marking the first time in a decade more than even three players hit the century mark in points!

McDavid won't have the luxury of entering the NHL amid plentiful new rules that favor offense, nor with a dual rookie class, as also occurred in 2005-06.

But what about the fact that McDavid will be joining the Oliers, and a top six that – barring any trades on draft day or over the summer – will likely consist of three proven scorers, plus a former #1 overall pick? While that might seem like a blessing, it could actually inhibit McDavid's scoring.

After all, there are only so many points to go around, and the last time one player had 82+ points while two of his teammates exceeded 70 was back in 2010-11, when it happened on two teams (98 for Corey Perry, 80 for Teemu Selanne, 70 for Ryan Getzlaf; 104 for Daniel Sedin, 94 for Henrik Sedin, 73 for Ryan Kesler). Notice a trend among those six? Not a rookie among them. In fact, all six players were as old (or older) than Hall, Eberle, Nugent-Hopkins, Yakupov, and McDavid when they accomplished the feat.

Beyond that, Crosby's 102 points as an 18 year old were the third most of all time at that age (Dale Hawerchuk had 103, Wayne Gretzky had 137). What's more, the fourth, fifth and sixth highest totals for 18 year olds were only 87, 79, and 68 points.

 

Who Wins

Of course no one really loses – not 2005 Crosby, not 2015 McDavid, nor poolies who were (or will be) fortunate enough to own either one. But the winner of the match is Crosby, who came into the NHL with a better track record and, perhaps most importantly, did so in a season with new rules that were all the more conductive to high scoring. Plus, Crosby defied the odds as an 18 year old in posting more than 87 points, which might be difficult for McDavid to achieve not only in general (it's happened only thrice in NHL history), but even more so given the points that will be spread around to others in the very talented Edmonton top six.

What does this mean for projecting McDavid's rookie stats versus 2005 Crosby's? To me, it seems all but assured that McDavid will fall well short of the 102 points that Crosby posted as a rookie. As for how that affects McDavid' value in general, and as compared to 2015 Crosby, check back here in two days to find out, when I'll present part two of this special Cage Match event.

 

 

Patrice Bergeron vs. David Krejci      
Mika Zibanejad vs. Mikael Granlund      
Alexander Semin vs. Joffrey Lupul      
Brayden Schenn vs. Marcus Johansson      
Alex Tanguay vs. Radim Vrbata      

 

 

 

Leave A Comment

UPCOMING GAMES

Mar 28 - 19:03 OTT vs CHI
Mar 28 - 19:03 TOR vs WSH
Mar 28 - 19:03 MTL vs PHI
Mar 28 - 19:03 PIT vs CBJ
Mar 28 - 19:03 FLA vs NYI
Mar 28 - 19:03 CAR vs DET
Mar 28 - 20:03 MIN vs S.J
Mar 28 - 20:03 STL vs CGY
Mar 28 - 20:03 WPG vs VGK
Mar 28 - 21:03 EDM vs L.A
Mar 28 - 21:03 COL vs NYR
Mar 28 - 22:03 SEA vs ANA
Mar 28 - 22:03 VAN vs DAL
Mar 28 - 22:03 ARI vs NSH

Starting Goalies

Top Skater Views

  Players Team
TAGE THOMPSON BUF
JJ PETERKA BUF
ANTHONY DUCLAIR T.B
JORDAN GREENWAY BUF
JURAJ SLAFKOVSKY MTL

Top Goalie Profile Views

  Players Team
ALEKSEI KOLOSOV PHI
JOONAS KORPISALO OTT
KAREL VEJMELKA ARI
UKKO-PEKKA LUUKKONEN BUF
JUSTUS ANNUNEN COL

LINE COMBOS

  Frequency DAL Players
23.3 MASON MARCHMENT MATT DUCHENE TY DELLANDREA
21.3 JASON ROBERTSON JOE PAVELSKI ROOPE HINTZ
18.8 SAM STEEL CRAIG SMITH RADEK FAKSA

DobberHockey Podcasts

FIND US ON FACEBOOK