Top 100 Keeper League Goaltenders – December 2016

by Dobber on December 20, 2016 | (18 Comments)

 

The Top 100 goalies to own in a fantasy hockey keeper league...

 

This month I posted the Top 50 here, and you can find the rest over at GoaliePost.com. Factoring in the depth chart, security as a starter, track record, injury history as well as current- and next year's outlook for putting up numbers. Goalies within the same 'tier' should be considered equal in value. However, I left the ratings in there if you really like to split hairs (I don't).

 

Coming on January 14th - Dobber's 10th annual Midseason Fantasy Guide! Pre-order it here right now

 

Dec 20 Goalie Team Rating Nov 20 Tier
1 Carey Price MON 106.6 2 0
2 Tuukka Rask BOS 105.9 3 1
3 Braden Holtby WAS 104.8 1 0
4 Martin Jones SJS 101.2 4 1
5 Sergei Bobrovsky CBJ 93.8 9 1
6 Corey Crawford CHI 91.7 6 1
7 Cam Talbot EDM 90.0 7 1
8 Devan Dubnyk MIN 89.3 15 1
9 Cory Schneider NJD 89.0 5 2
10 Henrik Lundqvist NYR 85.6 10 1
11 Ben Bishop TBL 84.9 8 2
12 Jake Allen STL 82.7 12 2
13 Matt Murray PIT 82.7 13 2
14 Steve Mason PHI 82.1 26 2
15 Connor Hellebuyck WPG 82.1 18 1
16 Pekka Rinne NSH 80.5 14 2
17 John Gibson ANA 80.1 16 2
18 Frederik Andersen TOR 78.5 21 2
19 Petr Mrazek DET 78.2 19 2
20 Marc-Andre Fleury PIT 77.1 11 2
21 Roberto Luongo FLA 75.9 17 2
22 Jonathan Quick LAK 75.5 23 1
23 Craig Anderson OTT 73.6 22 2
24 Andrei Vasilevskiy TBL 73.6 25 2
25 Chad Johnson CGY 72.9 43 3
26 Jacob Markstrom VAN 70.2 27 3
27 Jaroslav Halak NYI 65.6 24 2
28 Robin Lehner BUF 65.2 29 3
29 Antti Niemi DAL 64.3 32 3
30 Antti Raanta NYR 62.8 38 3
31 Cam Ward CAR 62.4 34 3
32 Kari Lehtonen DAL 62.2 30 3
33 Thomas Greiss NYI 61.2 33 3
34 Jimmy Howard DET 60.9 36 3
35 Calvin Pickard COL 59.8 35 3
36 Semyon Varlamov COL 58.7 20 3
37 Mike Smith ARI 58.6 39 3
38 James Reimer FLA 58.3 31 3
39 Philipp Grubauer WAS 57.8 40 4
40 Ryan Miller VAN 53.3 41 3
41 Louis Domingue ARI 52.8 37 3
42 Petr Budaj LAK 52.0 52 5
43 Scott Darling CHI 51.6 56 4
44 Anders Nilsson BUF 50.4 50 4
45 Michael Condon OTT 50.3 57 4
46 Brian Elliott CGY 48.0 28 3
47 Laurent Brossoit EDM 47.0 45 4
48 Michael Hutchinson WPG 45.6 46 4
49 Jonathan Bernier ANA 43.0 49 3
50 Darcy Kuemper MIN 42.6 47 4

 

Get the rest of the Top 100 HERE at Goalie Post!

 

Sign up for FREE email notifications about starting goalie changes - up to the minute - right here! Did I mention it's free?

 

  • jerrodedson99

    Dobber, I’m stuck…I’ve got two studs in goal (Holtby/Dubnyk) in my keeper pool. Next year my earliest draft pick is #6 (1,2,3 taken by players I’m keeping; 4,5 traded away). I’ve been offered Andersen and a 4 for Dubnyk. I know Dubnyk is far better this year but in the long term it helps my team…that 4 pick will land me a solid player next year, and are Andersen and the Leafs for real? In other words, this time next year, or the year after, this could look like a bargain. Thoughts? Or is Dubnyk a top 5 G for the next 3,4 years?

    • jerrodedson99

      The other thing, Dubnyk takes a #3 pick every year I keep him. Andersen takes an 11. (Where they were drafted.) So if I traded Dubnyk I’d have a #3 pick open every year.

      • jerrodedson99

        Or am I crazy to be having such high optimism for Andersen?

      • Dobber

        I think that’s a pretty good deal. Andersen will only get better. Dubnyk helps you right now so maybe delay it as late as possible

      • jerrodedson99

        News is out that I might move Dubnyk and I’ve just been offered Talbot. Is Talbot for real? It’s hard to judge the Oilers as, admittedly, I’m still biased, thinking any goalie in Edmonton is in trouble. But Talbot has good numbers…will it continue?

      • jerrodedson99

        After the Taylor Hall / Adam Larsson deal I remember reading how Corey Schneider said Larsson was unreplaceable.Schneider’s struggles this year can’t be a coincidence. And now Talbot has Larsson…

  • Jake Brimberry

    Who is worth pickin up in Colorado? Varlamov or Pickard..Either?? 10 team yahoo league. Isnt much out there as far as goalies go..thanks

  • Dave

    Finally Price where he should be!

  • 99rules66isafatbum

    W, S%, GAA, SO – yahoo keeper league, keep 1 goalie. By this list – you would recommend Helle boy over Bishop based on tiers but not in ranking? I am leaning toward the young keeper just based on age and injury proneness for Bish, but if you could confirm that would be great. Also, what to make of all the “Winnipeg is looking at goal tending options” noise. Why would they? Play the kid.

    • Dobber

      That is correct. And I could be wrong, but I am completely convinced that the Jets won’t get a goalie. They love Hellebuyck and will build the team around him

  • puckman

    Dubnyk leading most Goalie stats and still not top 3. Yet we find Jones and Talbot ahead of him !? Is this Yahoo inspired ?

    • Dobber

      This is a keeper league, right? Would you bet $1000 that he’ll be Top 3 next year? Year after? If I had $1000 for a bet like this, Dubnyk would rank 8th on the list of goalies I’d put it on.

      That being said, Dubnyk is Tier 1 and as I made clear up top – all Tier 1 goalies are equal.

      • Dave

        Dubnyk…its a safe bet to say that Dubnyk on Minnesota deserves to be top 5 regardless of 3 years from now. Next year there is no reason to want to own Jones on an aging Sharks team ahead of Dubnyk in MY opinion.

      • Jeff

        Start your own site : Daver and express that opinion.

  • Paul Evensen

    May I ask: If Bishop is out long term how would that affect Vasilevskiy’s placement in these rankings?

    • Dobber

      Vas will go up just as soon as he can help leagues this season – because his future is bright, so it’s only the ‘now’ that holds him down.

  • John

    Why is Hellebuyck tier 1 when Bob and Murray are tier 2?

    • Dobber

      Bob is an oversight. Should be 1. Murray will be 1 when fleury moves on

[shareaholic app="share_buttons" id="186673"] [shareaholic app="recommendations" id=""]