Ramblings: Goalies on the Move (July 19)

Ian Gooding

2017-07-19

Goalies on the move and why I might not like them as much as you do…

If you followed the free agent frenzy of July 1 on Twitter, you would have seen the announcement of a signing followed by a hockey person stating something to the effect of “Great signing. Exactly what they needed.”

For fantasy purposes, we evaluate things differently. We’ve developed a perception of Player X from both watching the games and our fantasy lineups. So what happens to our perception of that player once they join a new team?

Given the title above in today’s Ramblings, I’ll try not to be a total Debbie Downer when it comes to these goalies. But I guess I wasn’t quite as sold on some of these goalies as others were. I’m not saying that I won’t draft any of them, so I guess you could take this as a reality check in case you were sky high on any of them.

Scott Darling

Don’t get me wrong. I think Darling is clearly the best of this bunch, which is why I didn’t include him in the poll below. But I’ve heard rumblings that Darling will be a top-10 goalie by the end of the season and should be drafted as such. In that case, I can’t fathom ranking Darling ahead of more established safer bets such as Jonathan Quick, Ben Bishop, Martin Jones, or Tuukka Rask. I will say that I admire when someone takes a stand and believes that Darling will reach that top 10, as it makes for great discussion.

Darling’s career numbers as the Blackhawks’ backup are solid (2.37 GAA, .923 SV%). His new team is sneaky good at suppressing shots (28.3 SA/GP, 5th-best total in 2016-17). But as we do with every newly appointed starter, we need to bring up the fact that Darling has never played more than 32 games. How many games will the Hurricanes win? And with Cam Ward still in the mix, how many games will Darling actually start?

For the record, I’m not that concerned about the questions that I’ve listed. But in a 12-team league, you should be drafting Darling as a potential second goalie rather than a first.
 


Antti Raanta

Judging by the poll results, I didn’t think you folks would like Raanta as much as you did. Like Darling, Raanta has been elevated to a starting position thanks to great work as a backup. Raanta has posted a 2.17 goals-against average and a .924 save percentage over the last three seasons, including a 9th-ranked 2.26 goals-against average and an 11th-ranked .922 save percentage last season among goalies who played at least 25 games.

The Coyotes’ defense might be a different kettle of fish than the Rangers’ defense, though. The Rangers were middle of the pack with 30.1 shots allowed per game, but the Coyotes were second-worst with 34.1 shots allowed per game last season. If Raanta maintains a .920 save percentage, his goals-against average would finish somewhere around 2.60 with those extra four shots allowed. Not terrible, and the acquisition of Niklas Hjalmarsson could help further with that. But we haven’t grown accustomed to the Coyotes being strong defensively these last few years.

Need another reason not to like Raanta? The next goalie’s fantasy value is believed to have increased because he is now out of Arizona.

Mike Smith

With Smith, the belief is that his numbers will turn around now that he has the stout defense of the Flames in front of him. After all, he posted a 1.50 goals-against average and a .932 save percentage in eight games for gold-medal winning Team Canada at the 2015 World Hockey Championship. There’s lots to like with this situation, which is why many of you voted for Smith.

📢 advertisement:

But really, how much do you trust Mike Smith? For goalies that have played at least 75 games over the past three seasons (46 in all), Smith’s 2.96 goals-against average is the highest. Okay, so that’s partially the team in front of him. In the same group of goalies, Smith is 37th with a .911 save percentage. To compare, the likes of Semyon Varlamov and Ondrej Pavelec have a better save percentage over that span.

Despite that deep defense, I just can’t shake the feeling that Calgary has turned into a true goalie graveyard the last few seasons. Jonas Hiller, Karri Ramo, Joni Ortio, Chad Johnson, and the next goalie listed. Don’t get me wrong: Smith’s value improves with the trade. But I’m not drafting him any higher than a third goalie in a 12-team league.

Brian Elliott

What… where’s the love for Elliott? During his five-year term with the Blues, Elliott never posted a goals-against average higher than 2.28, and he posted a save percentage higher than .920 three of his five seasons. The stint in Calgary was a bit forgettable, but the expectations of being the guy didn’t work for him. Elliott never played more than 46 games over his five years for the Blues, yet he was forecast to start a lot more than that for the Flames.

But as he departs from one goalie graveyard, he arrives at another. When was the last time the Flyers’ goaltending looked alright? The Flyers have an up-and-coming defense, which should help. If Elliott plays the 35-45 games that seems to work for him, he should be fine ratios-wise. But his win total will be limited. Even on a St. Louis team that is strong during the regular season, Elliott has never once reached 30 wins in his career. But… I’m going to go contrarian on the poll question results and state that Elliott will be better than you think.

Steve Mason

Having owned Mason for the past two and a half seasons, he’s either been an integral part of my team or glued to my bench. No middle ground. When he’s on, he’s on, particularly if your league awards points for saves. But then he goes through spurts when he allows a minimum of three goals per game.

Don’t get me wrong: I think Mason has some value. I recently turned down an offer of Daniel Sedin for Mason, as Sedin basically has negative value with his current salary in this auction-style keeper league. But with the ups and downs that Mason has, we could see Connor Hellebuyck more than you initially assumed when the Jets announced the Mason signing. Also don’t forget that the Jets also still have Michael Hutchinson, turning this into a potential three-headed monster.

Whether it be Hellebuyck, Hutchinson, or Ondrej Pavelec, the Jets’ goaltending was brutal last season. The team’s 3.11 goals-against average was 27th in the NHL last season. So I wouldn’t be surprised if Paul Maurice just goes with whatever works here.

*

All in all, maybe we can conclude that these teams were in the market for goalies because they simply didn’t have good goaltending last season. The teams with good goaltending aren’t trying to fix their goaltending situations that aren’t broke.

Having said that, there’s no doubt that at least one of these goalies will exceed expectations next season, at least early on. The trick will be to find the right one.

*

For more fantasy hockey information, follow me on Twitter @Ian_Gooding.

4 Comments

  1. Brad Robar 2017-07-19 at 05:12

    I’m in a 14 team league and my goaltending situation is Dubnyk and Hellebuyck. I have an opportunity to a quite Smith cheap, so the question is who is the better goalie next year. Smith or Hellebuyck?

    • Dave 2017-07-19 at 07:43

      If you ask me, it depends on the time frame and your immediat possibilities of winning… Mason will allow Hellebuyck to find his game this year, and steal the net back next year… then Mason is out (contrat expires)… However, Smith’s contract is up at the same time as Mason’s, and clearly, Calgary is wants to force it’s window open now with all the acquisitions… IMO, Smith now, Hellebuyck for the next 7 years…

  2. GB 2017-07-19 at 13:53

    As a Flyers fan, it is clear Mason does not do well in tandem situations and will whine publicly when he gets frustrated with his role. He is not a team player even though his inconsistency as a goalie and the nature of the NHL support using a tandem for roster construction. The Flyers signed Elliott which is not by accident: they wanted someone willing to share the job and help younger goalies develop. They knew Mason was not in sync with that program. Hopefully WPG made it very clear to Mason that will not be acceptable.

    • MarkRM16 2017-07-20 at 16:48

      Elliott has to do well in tandems because he couldn’t stay healthy enough to play more than 60 games.

Leave A Comment

UPCOMING GAMES

Mar 19 - 19:03 DET vs CBJ
Mar 19 - 19:03 N.J vs PIT
Mar 19 - 19:03 PHI vs TOR
Mar 19 - 19:03 NYR vs WPG
Mar 19 - 19:03 BOS vs OTT
Mar 19 - 19:03 NYI vs CAR
Mar 19 - 20:03 NSH vs S.J
Mar 19 - 20:03 STL vs COL
Mar 19 - 21:03 EDM vs MTL
Mar 19 - 22:03 VGK vs T.B
Mar 19 - 22:03 L.A vs CHI
Mar 19 - 22:03 VAN vs BUF
Mar 19 - 22:03 ANA vs MIN

Starting Goalies

Top Skater Views

  Players Team
DANIIL MIROMANOV CGY
CONNOR MCMICHAEL WSH
CONNOR BEDARD CHI
EVGENY KUZNETSOV CAR
YEGOR SHARANGOVICH CGY

Top Goalie Profile Views

  Players Team
DUSTIN WOLF CGY
CHARLIE LINDGREN WSH
DANIIL TARASOV CBJ
DEVIN COOLEY S.J
JOEY DACCORD SEA

LINE COMBOS

  Frequency OTT Players
24.0 BRADY TKACHUK SHANE PINTO DRAKE BATHERSON
15.7 PARKER KELLY BORIS KATCHOUK MARK KASTELIC
14.4 TIM STUTZLE MATHIEU JOSEPH CLAUDE GIROUX

DobberHockey Podcasts

FIND US ON FACEBOOK

📢 advertisement: